Beneath the Smile: The Cost of People-Pleasing

Saying “no” and taking accountability for how you feel isn’t easy… and it’s even harder when you struggle with people-pleasing.

What is people-pleasing?

People-pleasing is the strong desire to please others, even at your own expense. You may feel your wants and needs do not matter, or you may mold yourself into what others want or need so that you can feel useful or loved. The desire to people-please is different from kindness, generosity, or altruism because you rarely feel as though you have the option to say “no” for fear of dislike or rejection, and you will likely go against how you really feel or what you really value to say “yes.”

What are some signs that you may be a people pleaser?

  • You pretend to agree with everyone and avoid voicing your honest opinion to be liked.
  • You feel responsible for how other people feel instead of letting them own their emotions.
  • You apologize often and excessively out of fear of others being upset with you.
  • You feel burdened by the things you need to do because you have trouble saying “no” to things.
  • You can’t say “no” to things, so you say “yes” and follow-through or find a way out later.
  • You feel uncomfortable when someone is angry with you, so you hide your own feelings.
  • You act like the people around you to make them feel happy or comfortable.
  • You need praise from others to feel validated in your own self-worth.
  • You go to great lengths to avoid conflict and do not stand-up for your own beliefs.
  • You don’t admit when your feelings are hurt, so your relationships remain superficial.

The problem is that while people-pleasing may make you feel good temporarily, the feeling never lasts.

Why do we people-please? Where does it come from?

  • Experiencing violence of a parent, caregiver, or partner
  • Experiencing and/or being a part of a group of people who experiences racism, discrimination, exclusion, or microaggression
  • Having an emotionally unavailable parent
  • Being in a relationship with a narcissistic partner or parent
  • Growing up in a family that avoided conflict or was full of conflict
  • Growing up with a parent or family member who struggled with persistent physical and/or mental health issues

Each of these situations holds one common factor: an environment where it is unsafe for you to say “no,” disagree, or be indifferent. And therefore, in order to cope, you become invisible, keep the peace, or put what others need and want above your own well-being.

So, how do we stop people-pleasing?

  • Committing to small goals for meeting needs like taking a small break in between meetings
  • Delaying your answer to a request by thinking about it rather than answering immediately
  • Limiting your time instead of allowing the other person to create your schedule
  • Blocking out time that is off-limits to any new requests or plans
  • Rehearsing how to say “no” in tactful and empathetic ways

What does God have to say about people-pleasing?

People-pleasing is an unsupportive pattern that stems from the spiritual wound of believing you are not worthy; that you are not safe until you take care of everyone around you. The problem is, when we avoid ourselves and refuse to tend to our own needs, we carry fear, rejection, judgement, and failure around instead.

We live in a world that places a high value on being liked, but we must remember that our true value is how we are loved by Christ. In Romans 12:2 God reminds us: “Do not be conformed to this world, but be transformed by the renewal of your mind, that by testing, you may discern what is the will of God, what is good and acceptable and perfect.” Today, know that you are good, acceptable, and perfect through Christ; not through those around you. And remember, that in Christ, you will always be enough.

References

Kendra Cherry, Mse. (2023, March 21). 8 ways to stop being a people-pleaser. Verywell Mind. https://www.verywellmind.com/how-to-stop-being-a-people-pleaser-5184412

MediLexicon International. (n.d.). People pleaser: Definition, signs, risks, and how to stop. Medical News Today. https://www.medicalnewstoday.com/articles/people-pleaser#definition

Sussex Publishers. (n.d.). 10 signs you’re a people-pleaser. Psychology Today. https://www.psychologytoday.com/us/blog/what-mentally-strong-people-dont-do/201708/10-signs-youre-people-pleaser

Payne, M. (2022, June 20). GoodTherapy.org. GoodTherapy. https://www.goodtherapy.org/blog/where-people-pleasing-comes-from/

PRESENTED BY

Carmine Vidaña

Therapist, Licensed Mental Health Counselor

BIO

  • Some facts / interests, etc.: 
    • Carmine has been married since 1992 with one grown daughter and two delightful grandchildren. Carmine has offered premarital counseling at her local church for over 25 years.
  • Languages Spoken: English/Spanish

Carol Valdivia-Bressan

Therapist, Registered Mental Health Counselor Intern

BIO

  • Some facts / interests, etc.: 
    • Carol has been married since 2023 and enjoys paddle boarding, spoken word, and hiking.
  • Languages Spoken: English/Spanish

LISTEN ON THE PODCAST

Insightful Conversations with Mental Health Experts

Tune in to our podcasts and listen to candid mental health conversations between our Wellspring therapists and diverse community guests. Wellspring’s podcasts offer a blend of Biblical wisdom, practical advice, and scientific insights, tailored to support everyone navigating the spectrum of mental health.

26 Min

If our lives are a collection of moments, our memories are a reel of the most significant ones.

29 Min

Learn to live intentionally by taking charge of your life instead of letting circumstances dictate it.

30 Min

To live balanced lives, investing in relationships that enhance and enrich our experiences is essential.

MORE RECENT BLOG POSTS

Mindful Reads for Daily Living

Are you a sucker for the New Year? Same. The fresh journal, the new stickers, the new pens. The carefully written “best-self habits” that will definitely start on January 1st, until a few days pass..

When we or a loved one “feel down,” we may be quick to dismiss it as just feeling sad. But when someone has depression, it is important to note that it goes far beyond “having..

CONTACT US

If you have any questions, feel free to reach out.